Join The Saratoga Special Readers Club for exclusive access to news, swag, discounts, special events and more

Opinion

Mr. Versatilities: Sheppard not only jump/flat champ trainer

Open a history book and start checking things. It’s not always wise, but it is fascinating. For, oh and I don’t know how long, it’s been relatively accepted that Jonathan Sheppard and Sidney Watters Jr. were the only two people to train a steeplechase champion and a flat champion in North America.

Sheppard’s horses won 13 year-end championships over jumps, led by Flatterer’s four and Café Prince’s two. Flat stars Informed Decision (2009 female sprint division) and Forever Together (2008 female turf division) added to the trainer’s Hall of Fame resume. For Watters, the jump titles came with Shadow Brook in 1971 and Amber Diver in 1963. His flat champions were Hoist The Flag (2-year-old male of 1970) and Slew O’ Gold (3-year-old male 1983). Like Sheppard, who was inducted in 1990, Watters joined racing’s Hall of Fame – way too late in 2005.

The rare dual-purpose feat deserves recognition, but Watters and Sheppard aren’t alone in that club. The roll call won’t take long, but it’s more than an exacta.

Peter Howe trained Soothsayer, the 1972 jump champion, and Proud Delta, the 1976 older filly/mare champion for main client, Montpelier.

Morris Dixon’s versatile stable included 1952 steeplechase champion Jam, and the champion sprinter of 1947 Polynesian.

And before you think the sprint/steeplechase double is unique, James E. Ryan won the 1949 sprint title with Royal Governor and the 1953 steeplechase crown with The Mast.

That’s five, with the possibility of a sixth if I can find some confirmation. Some reference guides list Hirsch Jacobs as the trainer of 1944 steeplechase champion Rouge Dragon. Others have W.G. Jones. I’m inclined to lean toward Jones based on repitition, but if it’s Jacobs he was also the man behind flat champions Stymie, Personality, Affectionally and Hail To Reason.

And that’s it. I think.

Sheppard, of course, recently announced his retirement and was even more recently honored by the New York Racing Association with the renaming of the Grade 1 New York Turf Writers Cup as the Jonathan Sheppard Stakes at Saratoga starting this summer. Honor him, applaud him, but don’t forget the other guys.

Almost a Year

If you want to talk, I’m always here.  That was the ending to an email I sent yesterday. To a friend. It goes for everyone.  Tough, trying times for all of us. We are all in this together. Miles starts his spring break today. Two weeks. It’s usually a tricky time, I’m winding down my … Read more

Still Running

The iRun Local Challenge continues. Behind schedule, but steadily ticking off the miles. Tom and I, the creators of such lunacy, are certainly lingering in the back of the pack, way off Joe, Brent, Ryan, Nolan and all the players. For all the reasons – injury, weather, motivation. Yeah, all the reasons. Tom is at … Read more

Saying Goodbyes

Receiving many reflective texts, calls, social media messages and emails regarding the column on Laura. I’m glad I could help in a small way. Challenging task to write about your friend who made such a positive impact and also created so much confusion.  Joe and I talk about it a lot, we never thought about … Read more

Anything but Tiny

The obituary reads two lines. 

Laura Thiel Shull, 56, of Camden, died Thursday, February 18, 2021. Arrangements will be announced by Kornegay Funeral Home, Camden Chapel.

I guess I’ll try to fill in the rest. Maybe she’d want me to, maybe she wouldn’t. 

A long and complicated life comes to a long and agonizing end. I can’t make sense of it. I have trouble making sense of her life and I can’t make sense of her death. Laura had a heart of gold, but it slowly, steadily drifted away, from her family, from her friends, from her causes, from her dreams. Parents gone. Brother on his own, somewhere. She was a friend of mine, a friend of yours, she adored our game, loved her town. She was the big little guy, supporting the underdog, rooting for the obscure, the challenged, the debauched, the flawed. 

Born and raised in Camden, Laura served on the NSA board of directors, served as president of SOTA, served as a longtime board member of the Carolina Cup and about every other board you can think of from equine to educational. She gave back, a philanthropist, a quiet, determined giver.

She was steeplechasing’s first slum lord, renting fixer-uppers on Mill, Chestnut, Haile to all the southbound steeplechase horsemen in Camden. Fair and straight, but strict, everybody signed a lease with Laura. Don’t be late with that rent check, either. 

She was an on-call, untrained counselor for a woman crisis hotline in the 90s. She used to take calls in the middle of the night – always Saturday night – and help out strangers, come back, bleary eyed and tired, but satisfied that she had tried, that she had made a difference.

She used to get a summer job waitressing at Chi-Chi’s. Worth more than the restaurant, Laura waited tables every summer when she and her first husband, Toby Edwards, would summer at Delaware Park. Active. She was always active, involved, always moving. Renting houses, selling fly sprayers for her dad, waiting tables, running a gift shop, a restaurant, leaping to action whenever a worthy cause arose. 

She won the flat race at Camden in 1994. As a jockey. In her dad’s silks, man was she proud. Yeah, her big horse, Message Pad, a front-running classic over the Neilson sisters. She said I misquoted her in Steeplechase Times. I probably did. 

Horses, dogs, cats, people…the strayer the better. 

She was enigmatic then, enigmatic all the way. Loved Mountain Dew and NASCAR. Smoked too much. Drank too much. Suffered through long, agonizing deaths of her mother, Judy, and her father, Dale. They didn’t want services, I wish they did. We should have been there for her, through those troubled times, I always thought that added to her demise. 

Her dad, the one-and-only inventor and entrepreneur, was a brilliant marketer, a born salesman, he gave his daughter a horse named Timely Encounter. He became her favorite – fast. She was hooked from there. He had upset the 1988 Temple Gwathmey, the longest shot on the board, Graham Alcock feathered in the feathery 137 pounds, there to fill the race, back when it was at Belmont Park and mattered that it filled. Two seasons later, the overachiever ran in Laura’s silks, a little pink to spice up the blue and black of her dad. 

The son of Northfields, who made his debut at Hialeah in 1986, won an allowance at Hard Scuffle in 1989, a handicap at Radnor in 1990, the Continental Cup at the Virginia Gold Cup in 1992, ran in the Carolina Cup five consecutive times, earning checks up and down the long road of steeplechasing back when it wound its way through places like Tanglewood and Marengo, Brookhill and Stoneybrook. Laura was there, at all of them. The clerk of scales at Camden, the TV host at Saratoga, Catherine French’s fill-in photographer at double meets. She was the one who picked up your tack bag and car keys and met you at Kershaw County Hospital or Aiken Regional Medical Center, giving you a bed for as long as you needed it, until whenever you remembered your name again and could head on home. 

Always with a smile and a good dose of reality. I cried on her shoulder a few times. She cried on mine. 

As Bill Price said a few days ago, “She was always thoughtful and reasonable with her answers.”

We lost her the last few years, sadly, she drifted away from me, you, all of us. Our lunches at the Everyday Gourmet became distant memories. I couldn’t reach her. Maybe I didn’t try hard enough. Alcohol took over, took her away from us. I don’t know if I should say that, don’t know if she would want me to say that, but I also know she always played it straight with me. Telling me when I was wrong when I thought I was right. Right when I thought I was wrong. 

They called her Tiny. She was anything but to her friends, her causes. Goodbye, my friend, our friend. Goodbye. 

Quiet Sunday

Miles off with Jazzy and the MOC Beagles. Annie dropping off, waiting, cheering, bringing home. A rare respite for me, a quiet house and a mountain of work. Laundry spinning. Notes transcribing. Emails flying. Auteuil, Huntingdon, Sedgefield, Leopardstown, Toulouse…racing.  The Gordon Elliott saga starting to settle, although, it will never be settled. The Irish Horse … Read more

On the Hunt

Knowing the best tonic is to stay on my feet, I just finished 5 miles on the Training Center Loop, trying to stretch and cajole the aches and pains. Calves, hamstrings and every fiber in my legs sore from yesterday’s excursion with the Piedmont Fox Hounds. I met Beamer, a 14-year-old son of Parker’s Storm … Read more

Friday Special

Taking the day off. A needed respite from the storm. Off to go hunting. Mellon country. Enjoy a day out. Crisp chill in the air. Blustery. Phone in the car. 

Book Report

As Ray Dalio says at the beginning of Principles, he’s not a writer. That’s true. Slow going through this one but it’s deserved. 

I like this one. 

And it reminded me that when faced with the choice between two things you need that are seemingly at odds, go slowly to figure out how you can have as much of both as possible. There is almost always a good path that you just haven’t figured out yet, so look for it until you find it rather than settle for the choice that is then apparent to you. 

Something to keep in mind when trying to make a tough decision. 

Next Stage

Outrage and anger now giving way to pity and redemption in the sad, sordid Gordon Elliott saga, playing out on Twitter and other mediums.

Perhaps, that’s good, the ability to forgive and forget. Perhaps. I’m going to have a hard time doing either. 

And, yes, we’ve all made mistakes. This was a big one by Elliott and his cronies. And, yes, when you’re a leader of a sport, you are judged publicicly, and perhaps, more severely. That’s part of the job. 

If Thoroughbred racing here is any guide, then, Elliott will be suspended for some period, a fine will be levied, the horses still in his care will transfer into someone else’s name, they’ll continue to run and win, Elliott will lay low for a while and at some point, it will all be gently swept under the rug as he returns to his helm and life will go on as normal. That’s what happens here. Time will tell what happens there.